Warehouse zoning

Warehouse · geometric LOD study drop 5 · atlas inputs release 2.4.0 · BEMGen 99c0b0adcd44

Prototype
Warehouse
Cells
24: 6 climate zones × 2 vintages × 2 orientations
Cells with a recommended zoning
2 of 24
Robust across orientations
1 of 12 cell pairs: Conditioned merge + Single zone building (1)
Reference zoning
No simplification + Stack
Reference zones
3
Most often recommended
Conditioned merge + Single zone building (2 of 24 cells)
Serial cost (R5)
timed in 1 of 24 cells (5A 90.1-2019 0°)
LOD recommendations 1.2.0, this prototype Downloadrelease 2.4.0 · SHA-256 8a3ea606d436aaf24e16a9a4422a31749681f00872098f97eaa5e5f6315889b4

Robust across orientations

Robust across orientations in 1 of 12 cell pairs (0° and 45°).

Climate zoneVintageRobust zoningZonesHeating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Area change %CPU ratioWall ratioMemory ratioPer orientation
2A90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
2A90.1-2019none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
2B90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
2B90.1-2019none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
3C90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
3C90.1-2019none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
4A90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
4A90.1-2019none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
5A90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
5A90.1-2019none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none
7A90.1-2007none meets the threshold at both orientations0°: none · 45°: none

For each prototype, climate zone and vintage, the robust zoning is the coarsest (fewest modelled zones) that meets the threshold at every orientation of the cell pair, by the writer's own verdict on each zoning at each orientation, with at most the reference's zone count, as the writer bounds a recommendation (D-220); a duplicate never meets, as the writer lists it. Ties at the fewest zones go to a zoning both orientations recommend, else to the first in the study's zoning order (simplifier, join pieces, perimeter depth, stacker, IWHT, FHT); the tied zonings are named. The errors reported are the worse of the orientations' values for each metric, so the row is a bound, not a mean; the cost ratios are the medians over the timed sites of that zoning in the pair. Where both orientations recommend the same zoning it is the robust one. A pair where no zoning meets the threshold at both orientations says so and names each orientation's own recommendation; the per-orientation rows below stay the reading for one orientation. The cost ratios are the median over the timed sites of the robust zoning in the pair (in this drop one orientation at most is timed, so the ratio is that site's); not timed where none is. The rule and its limits.

Every zoning by cell

2A · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference 46ef93ca5a92cdf1/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 0.3 and cooling 23.4 kWh/m²; peak heating 42.6 and cooling 69.0 kW. Sensible heating is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0834.4169.299.6100.0-85.9-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0834.4169.299.6100.0-85.9-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0834.0169.299.6100.0-85.3-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0833.8169.299.6100.0-85.2-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-60.4-66.2489.3113.860.466.2-46.9-67.1no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-61.3-62.6482.7107.361.362.6-38.2-63.5no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 46ef93ca5a92cdf1/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 46ef93ca5a92cdf1/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 46ef93ca5a92cdf1/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2A · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference 2b1f1ce69eb6f217/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 0.4 and cooling 23.2 kWh/m²; peak heating 42.8 and cooling 69.3 kW. Sensible heating is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0775.5170.399.6100.0-83.8-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0775.7170.399.6100.0-84.1-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0775.1170.399.6100.0-83.2-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-99.6-100.0774.9170.399.6100.0-83.0-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-54.1-64.4431.0111.154.164.4-46.6-62.9no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-55.6-60.8426.6104.655.660.8-37.9-59.5no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 2b1f1ce69eb6f217/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 2b1f1ce69eb6f217/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 2b1f1ce69eb6f217/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2A · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 43b67fcbf18f1cfa/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 0.2 and cooling 17.1 kWh/m²; peak heating 32.9 and cooling 51.1 kW. Sensible heating is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-100.0-100.0888.6169.6100.0100.0-100.0-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-60.8-63.0519.9108.260.863.0-53.3-63.8no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-61.4-59.3513.4101.661.459.3-59.5-60.1no
20 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 43b67fcbf18f1cfa/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 43b67fcbf18f1cfa/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 43b67fcbf18f1cfa/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2A · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference 8587eb5a442d2ce5/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 0.3 and cooling 17.0 kWh/m²; peak heating 33.0 and cooling 51.3 kW. Sensible heating is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-100.0-100.0815.5171.0100.0100.0-100.0-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-55.4-60.7454.0104.855.460.7-52.4-59.1no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-56.7-57.0451.398.256.757.0-57.3-55.8no
20 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8587eb5a442d2ce5/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 8587eb5a442d2ce5/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8587eb5a442d2ce5/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2B · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference ee674904385e0f52/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.8 and cooling 24.9 kWh/m²; peak heating 55.0 and cooling 80.7 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-80.8-98.9331.2179.280.898.97.6-52.4no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-80.9-98.9331.2179.280.998.97.6-52.2no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-80.7-98.9330.8179.280.798.97.8-52.1no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-80.6-98.9330.7179.280.698.97.8-52.1no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-45.8-64.8195.0120.945.864.810.9-47.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-46.9-61.7194.1114.746.961.710.0-48.9no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → ee674904385e0f52/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → ee674904385e0f52/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → ee674904385e0f52/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2B · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference 1cec11fb28dcb36e/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.9 and cooling 24.8 kWh/m²; peak heating 55.8 and cooling 81.9 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-81.7-99.0319.3180.781.799.07.3-54.6no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-81.8-98.9319.6180.681.898.97.2-54.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-81.5-99.0318.9180.781.599.07.4-54.3no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-81.4-98.9318.8180.781.498.97.4-54.2no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-41.4-62.7179.3118.341.462.710.5-49.1no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-42.7-59.5176.6111.842.759.59.6-51.2no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 1cec11fb28dcb36e/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 1cec11fb28dcb36e/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 1cec11fb28dcb36e/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2B · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 3270008cbbc98042/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.5 and cooling 18.9 kWh/m²; peak heating 41.0 and cooling 61.2 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-84.2-100.0346.1182.484.2100.011.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-84.3-100.0346.4182.484.3100.011.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-84.1-100.0345.9182.484.1100.011.8-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-84.0-100.0345.8182.484.0100.011.8-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-48.2-62.3201.7116.148.262.313.6-64.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-49.0-59.1203.4109.649.059.121.4-60.2no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 3270008cbbc98042/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 3270008cbbc98042/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 3270008cbbc98042/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

2B · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference 7483686749752e71/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.6 and cooling 18.8 kWh/m²; peak heating 41.6 and cooling 62.3 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-84.7-100.0332.6183.984.7100.011.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-84.8-100.0332.9183.984.8100.011.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-84.6-100.0332.4183.984.6100.011.8-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-84.6-100.0332.4183.984.6100.011.9-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-44.1-59.6185.9112.344.159.613.6-60.3no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-44.8-56.4185.7105.844.856.421.6-57.2no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 7483686749752e71/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 7483686749752e71/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 7483686749752e71/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

3C · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference 8a664cb3a93d7054/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.6 and cooling 1.3 kWh/m²; peak heating 32.0 and cooling 21.1 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-99.1-100.0332.5311.499.1100.0-40.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-99.1-100.0332.6311.499.1100.0-40.7-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-99.1-100.0332.5311.499.1100.0-40.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-99.1-100.0332.5311.499.1100.0-40.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-54.5-52.9183.0169.854.552.9-37.9-58.2no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-55.6-51.9182.5161.455.651.9-39.7-57.7no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8a664cb3a93d7054/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 8a664cb3a93d7054/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8a664cb3a93d7054/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

3C · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference c1b1e94f35ae3a34/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 1.7 and cooling 1.3 kWh/m²; peak heating 32.0 and cooling 21.3 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-99.2-100.0319.2321.199.2100.0-41.5-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-99.3-100.0319.3321.199.3100.0-42.0-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-99.2-100.0319.1321.199.2100.0-41.3-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-99.2-100.0319.1321.199.2100.0-41.2-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-50.1-43.0168.5151.550.143.0-38.7-50.1no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-51.2-42.7167.1143.151.242.7-40.9-47.6no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → c1b1e94f35ae3a34/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → c1b1e94f35ae3a34/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → c1b1e94f35ae3a34/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

3C · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 575929fdd55b0e42/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 2.4 and cooling 0.8 kWh/m²; peak heating 32.7 and cooling 13.3 kW. Sensible cooling is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-91.5-100.0253.2312.991.5100.0-10.5-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-91.6-100.0253.4312.991.6100.0-10.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-91.5-100.0253.0312.991.5100.0-10.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-91.4-100.0252.9312.991.4100.0-10.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-53.5-60.1148.4174.153.560.10.6-51.4no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-53.5-60.6147.7172.953.560.6-10.9-51.0no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 575929fdd55b0e42/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 575929fdd55b0e42/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 575929fdd55b0e42/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

3C · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference cf1566d54d58e524/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 2.5 and cooling 0.8 kWh/m²; peak heating 32.6 and cooling 13.5 kW. Sensible cooling is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-92.3-100.0248.2321.892.3100.0-10.7-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-92.3-100.0248.3321.892.3100.0-10.8-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-92.2-100.0248.0321.892.2100.0-10.7-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-92.2-100.0247.9321.892.2100.0-10.7-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-50.2-46.4138.5139.550.246.43.2-37.6no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-50.8-48.3139.4140.850.848.3-12.5-35.3no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → cf1566d54d58e524/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → cf1566d54d58e524/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → cf1566d54d58e524/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

4A · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference 8bc7d49fc68cc151/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 29.6 and cooling 5.9 kWh/m²; peak heating 172.7 and cooling 49.3 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-9.5-100.025.1287.39.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-9.5-100.025.1287.39.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-9.5-100.025.1287.39.5100.0-1.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-9.5-100.025.2287.39.5100.0-1.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-4.6-67.217.3193.34.667.22.5-66.2no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-4.3-63.216.5181.44.363.22.3-62.4no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8bc7d49fc68cc151/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 8bc7d49fc68cc151/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8bc7d49fc68cc151/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

4A · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference 773fa5133a5b3e06/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 29.6 and cooling 6.0 kWh/m²; peak heating 173.9 and cooling 50.3 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-9.8-100.025.7287.29.8100.0-2.3-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-10.0-100.025.8287.210.0100.0-2.3-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-9.8-100.025.8287.29.8100.0-2.3-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-9.8-100.025.8287.29.8100.0-2.3-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-4.3-63.217.3183.84.363.21.8-61.8no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-4.1-59.216.4171.84.159.21.6-58.2no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 773fa5133a5b3e06/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 773fa5133a5b3e06/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 773fa5133a5b3e06/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

4A · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 017354c84a3f3daf/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 32.5 and cooling 4.4 kWh/m²; peak heating 168.0 and cooling 40.9 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-8.3-100.021.1299.68.3100.0-1.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-8.3-100.021.1299.68.3100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-8.3-100.021.2299.68.3100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-8.2-100.021.2299.68.2100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-3.9-65.115.0194.83.965.12.3-64.4no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-3.7-61.014.4182.33.761.02.1-60.8no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 017354c84a3f3daf/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 017354c84a3f3daf/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 017354c84a3f3daf/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

4A · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference 8608fb3da60d560c/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 32.5 and cooling 4.5 kWh/m²; peak heating 167.9 and cooling 41.8 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-8.5-100.021.6299.68.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-8.5-100.021.6299.68.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-8.5-100.021.7299.68.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-8.5-100.021.7299.68.5100.0-1.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-3.7-60.415.1183.03.760.42.3-59.7no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-3.6-56.414.4170.73.656.42.1-56.1no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8608fb3da60d560c/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 8608fb3da60d560c/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 8608fb3da60d560c/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

5A · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference 0a7e405d77fa7252/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 57.8 and cooling 2.2 kWh/m²; peak heating 231.2 and cooling 36.6 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-5.8-100.014.1394.65.8100.0-3.4-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-5.8-100.014.1394.65.8100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-5.8-100.014.1394.65.8100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-5.8-100.014.1394.65.8100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-2.5-67.110.0266.42.567.1-0.5-67.5no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-2.4-62.99.6249.52.462.9-0.6-64.0no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 0a7e405d77fa7252/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 0a7e405d77fa7252/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 0a7e405d77fa7252/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

5A · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference 36e70aab6f6e31ba/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 57.8 and cooling 2.2 kWh/m²; peak heating 231.0 and cooling 37.6 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-5.9-100.014.2394.35.9100.0-3.4-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-6.0-100.014.3394.36.0100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-5.9-100.014.3394.35.9100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-5.9-100.014.3394.35.9100.0-3.4-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-2.4-60.410.0245.22.460.4-0.4-58.4no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-2.3-56.59.6228.52.356.5-0.6-55.4no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 36e70aab6f6e31ba/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 36e70aab6f6e31ba/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 36e70aab6f6e31ba/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

5A · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 71c25b12627b2672/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 56.7 and cooling 1.3 kWh/m²; peak heating 205.3 and cooling 27.2 kW. Serial cost (R5): processor time 3.2 s, wall clock 3.2 s, peak committed memory 189 MiB, each the median of 3 repeats (processor-time CV 0.6 %); a zoning's ratios are its own medians over the reference's.

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %CPU ratioWall ratioMemory ratioMeets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-5.0-100.012.6415.05.0100.0-0.9-100.00.2780.2910.978no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-5.1-100.012.6415.05.1100.0-0.9-100.00.8830.8890.996no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-5.0-100.012.6415.05.0100.0-0.9-100.00.3510.3580.980no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-5.0-100.012.6415.05.0100.0-0.9-100.00.3510.3750.984no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-2.3-67.09.3272.82.367.01.7-67.10.6390.7000.998no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-2.2-62.49.0253.12.262.41.6-62.90.6490.6690.995no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 71c25b12627b2672/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 71c25b12627b2672/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 71c25b12627b2672/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

5A · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference 114ca7bd1e1decb0/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 56.7 and cooling 1.4 kWh/m²; peak heating 206.4 and cooling 27.5 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-5.1-100.012.7412.55.1100.0-1.5-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-5.1-100.012.7412.55.1100.0-1.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-5.1-100.012.7412.55.1100.0-1.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-5.1-100.012.7412.55.1100.0-1.5-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-2.3-58.49.4242.12.358.41.1-57.6no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-2.2-54.19.0223.02.254.11.0-54.5no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 114ca7bd1e1decb0/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 114ca7bd1e1decb0/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 114ca7bd1e1decb0/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

7A · 90.1-2007 · 0°

Reference b2d6f3f9d2975688/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 87.9 and cooling 1.6 kWh/m²; peak heating 287.5 and cooling 36.2 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.06.9413.82.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.06.9413.82.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.06.9413.82.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.07.0413.82.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-0.3-65.64.9273.10.365.6-0.3-67.5no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-0.3-61.44.7255.90.361.4-0.4-63.7no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → b2d6f3f9d2975688/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → b2d6f3f9d2975688/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → b2d6f3f9d2975688/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

7A · 90.1-2007 · 45°

Reference 503d54dca2a3e8e1/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 87.8 and cooling 1.7 kWh/m²; peak heating 287.4 and cooling 37.9 kW. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Conditioned merge + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.07.0413.52.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
No simplification + Single zone building10.00-2.8-100.07.0413.52.8100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building10.00-2.7-100.07.0413.52.7100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building10.00-2.8-100.07.1413.52.8100.0-2.6-100.0no
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-0.2-56.65.0242.40.256.6-0.3-61.2no
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-0.2-52.74.7225.30.252.7-0.4-57.8no
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 503d54dca2a3e8e1/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 503d54dca2a3e8e1/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 503d54dca2a3e8e1/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

7A · 90.1-2019 · 0°

Reference 86e77eea978295c1/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 67.4 and cooling 0.5 kWh/m²; peak heating 205.3 and cooling 14.8 kW. Sensible cooling is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-0.8-72.35.4287.40.872.31.3-60.1yes, finer than the reference
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-0.8-69.05.1271.00.869.01.2-55.8yes, finer than the reference
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 86e77eea978295c1/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 86e77eea978295c1/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 86e77eea978295c1/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

7A · 90.1-2019 · 45°

Reference 51aee3c9e47b2b2b/R: No simplification + Stack, 3 zones, 4,598 m² conditioned; annual sensible heating 67.4 and cooling 0.6 kWh/m²; peak heating 205.2 and cooling 16.2 kW. Sensible cooling is below 1 kWh/m² and is not judged. This cell was not timed in the serial pass (R5).

ZoningZonesArea change %Heating error %Cooling error %Heating CV(RMSE) %Cooling CV(RMSE) %Heating NMBE %Cooling NMBE %Peak heating error %Peak cooling error %Meets the threshold
Perimeter core 3 m + Stack50.00-0.7-57.05.4225.50.757.01.4-47.5yes, finer than the reference
Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack50.00-0.7-54.25.2211.00.754.21.3-43.3yes, finer than the reference
17 zonings write the same model as a listed one and are not shown
  • Conditioned merge + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Conditioned merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • No simplification + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 51aee3c9e47b2b2b/R
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 3 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 3 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 3 m + Stack
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone per floor type → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Single zone building
  • Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Perimeter core 4.57 m + Stack
  • Semantic merge + Single zone building → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Single zone per floor type → No simplification + Single zone building
  • Semantic merge + Stack → 51aee3c9e47b2b2b/R
  • Semantic merge + Stacked floor zone multiplier → 51aee3c9e47b2b2b/R
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone building → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Single zone per floor type → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stack → Conditioned merge + Single zone building
  • Single zone per floor + Stacked floor zone multiplier → Conditioned merge + Single zone building

Atlas programs

The atlas programs each program key of the prototype takes, as the suite's saved inputs name them (release 2.4.0 IDs); the prototype's geometry and glazing are BEMGen's DOE record. Method and caveats.